The construction industry needs specialized construction ERP systems due to the unique requirements for accounting and payroll. And that is probably the reason why accountants need to go through another course on construction accounting if they plan to switch to this industry.
ERP Selection: The Ultimate Guide
This is an in-depth guide with over 80 pages and covers every topic as it pertains to ERP selection in sufficient detail to help you make an informed decision.
Additionally, any industry that might not be in the core construction business but might barely touch it or sells to it might also inherit a lot of processes from it. For example, the manufacturers that sell to the construction industries might need to go through the same pre-construction, bidding, and submittal process. Similarly, the contractors such as electrical, plumbing, and HVAC might also go through the same process and may require some of these specific feature sets.
For this reason, the ERP systems not designed for construction accounting and industries might feel unnatural. So what are the construction ERP systems and how to evaluate them? How about we start with the list of the top 10 construction ERP systems that are most often installed in the construction industry? To finalize this list, we have analyzed hundreds of ERP systems and their capabilities through publicly available information. The list also relies on our teams’ experience in evaluating these ERP systems for our customers. The purpose of this article is not to recommend them but to shortlist some of these options that you should vet further as per your needs. Ready to review the list?
Criteria
- Overall market share/# of customers. The higher the market share of the product, the higher it ranks on our list.
- Ownership/funding. The more committed is the management to the product roadmap, the higher it ranks on our list.
- Quality of development (legacy vs. legacy dressed as modern vs. modern UX/cloud-native). The more cloud-native are construction capabilities, the higher it ranks on our list.
- Community/Ecosystem. The larger the community for the construction product, the higher it ranks on our list.
- Depth of native functionality for specific industries. The deeper the construction functionality provided out-of-the-box that the publisher owns, the higher it ranks on our list.
- Quality of publicly available product documentation. The poorer the product documentation, the lower it ranks on our list.
- Construction product share and documented commitment of the publisher through financial statements. The higher the focus on construction, the higher the ERP system ranks on our list.
- Ability to natively support diversified business models. The more diverse the product, the higher it ranks on our list.
- Acquisition strategy aligned with construction. The more aligned the acquisitions are with construction, the higher it ranks on our list.
- User Reviews. The deeper the reviews on public sites by construction companies, the higher the score for a specific product.
- Must be an ERP product. It can’t be an edge product such as Salesforce, ProCore, Adeaca, InEight, or ServiceNow. It also can’t be an add-on owned by ISVs or VARs that sits on top of other accounting platforms.
The 2024 Digital Transformation Report
Thinking of embarking on a ERP journey and looking for a digital transformation report? Want to learn the best practices of digital transformation? Then, you have come to the right place.
10. CMiC
CMiC is a purpose-built construction management software designed for construction companies. Unlike Acumatica or Sage Intacct which were born in the cloud, CMiC is migrating its legacy platform to the cloud.
CMiC supports construction accounting, job codes, percentage of completion accounting, and union payroll needs. They also have many features such as project submittal, collaboration on RFPs, estimation, etc. By contrast, other software would require systems such as ProCore for their operational needs.
While CMiC’s primary target market includes SMBs, it has been able to acquire some larger customers with more than 3,000 employees. That said, CMiC’s overall revenue share in the construction space is still much smaller than other bigger competitors such as Deltek and Trimble. For these reasons, there is no change in the CMiC’s rank this year and still maintains the rank at #10 on our list of top 10 construction ERP systems.
9. Viewpoint
Like CMiC, Viewpoint is also a legacy vendor in the construction space. After its acquisition by Trimble, it can offer much deeper construction management functionality. However, while they have made efforts to move their legacy codebase to the cloud, most of the screens still have a very on-prem appearance.
Like CMiC, Viewpoint can support the majority of the needs of your construction business, including construction management, estimating, construction finance, equipment management, etc. Viewpoint’s revenue share is much larger than CMiC’s in the construction space but lower than Deltek’s. Its recent valuation during its sale to Trimble was $1.2 billion. For these reasons, there is no change in Viewpoint’s rank this year and still maintains the rank at #9 on our list of top 10 construction ERP systems.
8. Unanet
Unlike CMiC and Viewpoint, Unanet targets Architectural and Engineering firms with deep DCAA compliance needs for Gov Contractors like Deltek. Also, unlike its legacy counterparts, Unanet has a modern cloud-native interface.
While Unanet can provide a complete package for project-centric firms, it still sits on top of other accounting packages such as Sage or SAP. They do it in the two-tier setting when larger companies need superior financial control at the corporate level. Furthermore, Unanet has a smaller market share than Viewpoint.
7. Microsoft Dynamics 365 F&O
Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations targets enterprise companies with more than 10-15 entities. Generally, in the construction industry, most SMBs may have more entities than other industries due to their business model. These companies typically have one entity per project, depending upon the complexity and financial risk of the project. But their transaction volume is lower compared to retail or manufacturing.
While Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations may not contain the operational functionality as rich as some of the best-of-breed solutions, larger companies typically prefer financial control at the corporate level. Therefore, they use other MS Dynamics F&O add-ons such as Adeaca for operational needs in a two-tier setting. These companies may also require more add-ons or custom development to support features related to construction.
Additionally, MS365 F&O has native integration for the field service, HCM, and CRM at the database layer that can assist large companies in building the best-of-breed architecture. For these reasons, there is no change in Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations’ rank this year and it still maintains the rank at #7 on our list of top 10 construction ERP systems.
6. SAP S/4 HANA
Like Microsoft Dynamics 365 F&O, S/4 HANA targets enterprise companies with more than 10-15 entities. Both solutions offer much tighter integration of resourcing and procurement inside the projects. And this functionality helps companies manage their supply chain, resourcing, and forecasting.
Both of these solutions also include strong field service components. SAP S/4 HANA also has other solutions in its portfolio that can be used in best-of-breed settings, such as SuccessFactors for HCM and Concur. In addition, companies use SAP S/4 HANA in conjunction with other best-of-breed solutions from other vendors such as Salesforce for CRM and Workday for HCM.
While SAP S/4 HANA is behind the cloud in the operational ERP capabilities, the financial capabilities are enough for most construction companies as the operational ERP functionality provided by vanilla ERP systems may not be as relevant in the construction space. These companies would require another construction-centric package such as Unanet or Procore in the two-tier setting to meet their operational construction needs. For these reasons, there is no change in SAP S/4 HANA’s rank this year and still maintains the rank at #6 on our list of top 10 construction ERP systems.
5. Oracle ERP Cloud
Unlike SAP S/4 HANA and Microsoft Dynamics 365 F&O, Oracle ERP Cloud is a clear leader in construction in the enterprise space with deep operational functionality for construction-centric businesses.
Oracle ERP Cloud portfolio for construction contains several products such as Oracle Aconex for design and construction coordination and Primavera products for project and portfolio management. In addition, Oracle includes Textura payment for streamlining subcontractor invoicing and payment and other products for submittals management in the pre-construction phase and collaboration among GCs and sub-contractors.
These operational capabilities provide a significant edge for Oracle in these industries compared to its other competitors in the enterprise space, such as Microsoft F&O and SAP S/4 HANA.
While Oracle might not have as deep last mile functionality for government contractors such as Deltek, Sage, or Unanet, they are far more globalized and localized to meet the needs of large public construction firms. For these reasons, there is no change in Oracle ERP Cloud’s rank this year and still maintains the rank at #5 on our list of top 10 construction ERP systems.
4. Deltek
Deltek has a large market share in the construction and GovCon space, with its last valuation being $2.8B in 2016. With this market valuation, they are much larger than their legacy competitors. They are also one of the largest in the GovCon space and have won logos such as AWS and Booz Allen Hamilton for their GovCon functionality.
Deltek solution is far ahead with its cloud-native functionality compared to the smaller vendors such as Viewpoint and CMiC. And their solution has been adopted by much larger construction firms.
Also, Deltek has an edge due to the deeper penetration in the ecosystem. The larger GCs that might be on Deltek typically require their sub-cons to be operating on the Deltek platform. They do so due to the collaboration synergies during the pre-construction or bidding phase.
While Deltek may not have as deep globalized functionality as Oracle ERP Cloud, it’s deeper in its operational capabilities, making it ideal for upper mid-market organizations. In addition, while there are many solutions in the smaller space, Deltek doesn’t have much competition in the upper mid-market space. For these reasons, there is no change in Deltek’s rank this year and still maintains the rank at #4 on our list of top 10 construction ERP systems.
3. Sage Intacct
Unlike Acumatica, Sage Intacct’s core target market is service-centric industries, including construction. Construction has also been one of the largest revenue drivers for Sage through its Sage 300 CRE product.
While Sage Intacct may not have as large a construction market share today compared to other competing products and Sage 300 CRE, its design suits construction-centric industries with its depth in multi-entity functionality and native consolidation capabilities. Sage Intacct also has native integration with ProCore, making them an ideal and killer combination as a cloud-native solution that other competing solutions can’t match.
While Sage Intacct’s design is superior for construction compared to other cloud-native products, which are primarily designed for product-centric industries, its entity-based pricing puts it at a disadvantage compared to Acumatica. But once Sage Intacct develops richer capabilities similar to Sage 300 CRE, Sage is likely to have a migration path for customers moving from the CRE product.
This move will help Sage Intacct acquire a much larger construction market share than most competitors. But as of today, Sage Intacct is weaker for the construction industry and might fall short with critical functions such as union reporting. For these reasons, we have reduced Sage Intacct’s ranking but it still maintains the rank at #3 on our list of top 10 construction ERP systems.
2. Acumatica
Like Sage Intacct, Acumatica is among the top three cloud-native products. In addition, Acumatica has a construction edition with deep capabilities for construction-centric field services and construction payroll and job codes.
While Acumatica does not have as rich multi-entity functionality, it has pre-baked integration with ProCore. Also, its consumption-based pricing makes it very attractive for construction companies that deploy several third-party contractors and seasonal workers depending upon the project’s demand.
Acumatica may require several add-ons to match the depth of Deltek and Sage 300 CRE for DCAA compliance etc. But the core accounting, project management, field service, construction job management, and cost codes tracking are likely to be richer. For these reasons, Acumatica maintains the rank at #2 on our list of the top 10 construction ERP systems.
1. Sage 300 CRE
Sage 300 CRE has been the undisputed leader in the construction and real estate space. It has extremely rich construction accounting functionality and deeper and native integration with ProCore, the strongest cloud-native platform for construction management.
Sage 300 CRE might not have as strong AE and GovCon functionality and might require an add-on to support that. But due to the financial backing of Sage, it’s still a very attractive solution for SMB companies that require deep construction accounting, estimation, job cost codes, projects with procurement, etc.
Sage 300 CRE technology may not be as advanced today. But it’s functionally complete for construction companies. Other solutions would require substantial development on top of the vanilla ERP systems. Also, integration with operational systems such as ProCore might be equally expensive and technically risky. For these reasons, we have moved up Sage 300 CRE in the ranking and now maintain the rank at #1 on our list of the top 10 construction ERP systems.
Conclusion
The construction industry has unique processes and accounting needs. The generalized ERP systems will fall short of meeting the needs of construction businesses. The ERP selection may be even trickier if your industry may be a hybrid of construction and manufacturing or construction and service repair or distribution.
So if you are evaluating a construction ERP system, make sure you understand and look for unique capabilities that will be a critical success factor for your implementation. And hopefully, this list can provide you with some options that might be potentially suitable for you.
